FT
Columbus Crew
1
–
0
New York City FC
—
FT
Toronto FC
1
–
0
New York City FC
—
FT
New York City FC
0
–
1
Philadelphia Union
Sub
FT
New York City FC
1
–
3
Orlando City SC
Started
FT
Inter Miami
0
–
1
New York City FC
Sub
FT
Toronto FC
1
–
3
New York City FC
Sub
FT
New York City FC
1
–
3
Portland Timbers
Sub
FT
New York Red Bulls
1
–
0
New York City FC
Sub
FT
New York City FC
1
–
0
Columbus Crew
Sub
FT
New York City FC
3
–
1
Chicago Fire
Sub
FT
New England Revolution
0
–
2
New York City FC
Sub
FT
DC United
0
–
0
New York City FC
Sub
FT
New York City FC
2
–
1
FC Cincinnati
Started
FT
New England Revolution
0
–
0
New York City FC
Started
FT
New York City FC
0
–
1
Toronto FC
Started
FT
New York City FC
4
–
0
FC Cincinnati
Sub
FT
Inter Miami
2
–
3
New York City FC
Sub
FT
New York City FC
4
–
1
DC United
Sub
FT
New York City FC
1
–
2
New England Revolution
Started
FT
Orlando City SC
1
–
1
New York City FC
Started
FT
Columbus Crew
3
–
1
New York City FC
Sub
FT
New York City FC
3
–
1
CF Montreal
Started
FT
Toronto FC
0
–
1
New York City FC
Sub
FT
New York City FC
5
–
2
New York Red Bulls
Sub
FT
Chicago Fire
3
–
4
New York City FC
Sub
FT
Orlando City SC
1
–
1
New York City FC
Sub
Faded rows: team matches without G. Þórarinsson in the lineup