FT
Rosario Central
1
–
0
Penarol
—
FT
Penarol
5
–
0
Caracas FC
—
FT
Atletico-MG
3
–
2
Penarol
—
FT
Caracas FC
0
–
1
Penarol
—
FT
Penarol
2
–
0
Atletico-MG
—
FT
Penarol
2
–
1
Rosario Central
—
FT
Penarol
4
–
0
The Strongest
—
FT
The Strongest
1
–
0
Penarol
—
FT
Flamengo
0
–
1
Penarol
—
FT
Penarol
0
–
0
Flamengo
—
FT
Botafogo
5
–
0
Penarol
—
FT
Penarol
3
–
1
Botafogo
—
Faded rows: team matches without S. Mülhethaler in the lineup