FT
Cleveland SC
1
–
0
Akron City
—
FT
Cleveland SC
6
–
0
Niagara 1812
—
FT
SI Guardians
2
–
7
Cleveland SC
—
FT
Steel City
2
–
0
Cleveland SC
—
FT
Michigan Rangers
5
–
0
Cleveland SC
—
FT
Cleveland SC
8
–
1
SI Guardians
—
FT
Akron City
3
–
0
Cleveland SC
—
FT
Cleveland SC
3
–
2
Erie Commodores
—
FT
Cleveland SC
1
–
1
Michigan Rangers
—
FT
Flower City Union
3
–
1
Cleveland SC
—
Faded rows: team matches without A. Nicholas in the lineup