FT
St. Louis City
2
–
1
Houston Dynamo
Sub
FT
Houston Dynamo
1
–
0
St. Louis City
—
FT
Houston Dynamo
0
–
1
Columbus Crew
—
FT
Columbus Crew
1
–
1
Houston Dynamo
—
Faded rows: team matches without Obafemi Awodesu in the lineup